Technical Report: Multiplicative versus Ratio Comparisons

ABSTRACT
Claims such as “Our product whitens teeth twice as well as product X!” abound in advertising. Such claims have traditionally been viewed as statements regarding ratios of product performances and have been treated accordingly. In previous technical reports, we have both reviewed and extended traditional ratio based statistical methods used to evaluate such claims. In this report we offer a new perspective, one that is both more natural and more powerful. In particular, we propose a shift away from ratio based comparisons towards what we term multiplicative comparisons. This means that instead of viewing the above claim as a statement that our product’s performance divided by the performance of product X is at least two, we instead consider whether the efficacy of our product is at least twice the efficacy of product X. This change might seem trivial, but we show below that this change is both more generally applicable and is more powerful than a ratio based approach. In what follows, we review our recent statistical work on a multiplicative approach to evaluate product claims and we compare this multiplicative approach to the ratio based approaches that follow in the classical tradition.


This technical report appears as:
Ennis, J. M. and Ennis, D. M. (2009). Multiplicative versus Ratio Comparisons. IFPress, 12(2) 2-3.

Colleagues can download the entire technical report here:
Multiplicative versus Ratio Comparisons

Not a Colleague? Click here to join for free!

This technical report also appears in our book, Tools and Applications of Sensory and Consumer Science.

Tags: , , , ,

site search



Upcoming Webinar

June 15, 2017
2PM EDT

Claiming Equivalence, Unsurpassed, and Superiority Simultaneously

__________________

Announcing the release of the 2016 Webinar Series Package!

Offered at a discounted rate of 50% off regular price, this package contains recordings of all four webinars offered during the 2016 Quarterly Webinar Series.

Create Your Own Webinar Package

__________________

Webinar calendar

Membership

Become a Colleague!

Join now to gain access to our technical reports, presentations, and more!

Click here to login or join.

Latest Technical Report

Societies