Technical Report: Comparing Perceptual Noise in Rating Scales

ABSTRACT
In the Southern District of New York in 2011, Church & Dwight Co. Inc. (C&D) sought a preliminary injunction barring The Clorox Company (Clorox) from continuing to air a commercial that implied that Clorox’s cat litter product was superior to C&D’s at eliminating cat waste malodor. This preliminary injunction was granted in early 2012. Among a number of legal and technical issues in the case was the implausibility that eleven trained panelists would report a score of zero in each of four replications to a previously sealed jar containing a carbon and cat waste sample. The rating instrument used was a 15-point malodor scale with 0.1 unit increments, effectively making it a 151-point scale and previous research from Clorox had shown that human subject ratings of cat litter with or without cat waste are quite variable. C&D argued that such a result is “highly implausible” given that the test used humans, which are known to be “noisy instruments” when it comes to olfactory perception. The court explained that this is because humans “for neurological reasons, perceive the exact same thing differently at different times and report the presence of olfactory stimuli even when they do not exist.”

This technical report appears as:
Ennis, D. M. (2015). Comparing Perceptual Noise in Rating Scales. IFPress, 18(3) 3-4.

Download this technical report here:
Comparing Perceptual Noise in Rating Scales

site search



Upcoming Webinar

June 15, 2017
2PM EDT

Claiming Superiority and Equivalence Simultaneously?!?

__________________

Announcing the release of the 2016 Webinar Series Package!

Offered at a discounted rate of 50% off regular price, this package contains recordings of all four webinars offered during the 2016 Quarterly Webinar Series.

Create Your Own Webinar Package

__________________

Webinar calendar

Membership

Become a Colleague!

Join now to gain access to our technical reports, presentations, and more!

Click here to login or join.

Latest Technical Report

Societies