Technical Report: Claiming Superiority and Equivalence Simultaneously

The ASTM Standard Guide for Sensory Claim Substantiation specifies the criteria for superiority, equivalence, and unsurpassed claims. A summary of these types of claims is outlined in Figure 1.

Figure 1. Types of advertising claims.

Equivalence claims are based on a binary choice between two products and involve two bounds set at 45% and 55%. Within these bounds, two products are considered to be equivalent. Superiority claims are established when a choice probability (usually preference, but not always) exceeds 50%. Unsurpassed claims are made when the choice probability exceeds 45%. The idea behind this latter choice is based on the definition of an unsurpassed claim. An unsurpassed claim combines the concept of equivalence, with a 45% lower bound, and superiority, which has an upper bound of 100%.

Figure 2. Bounds defining advertising claim types.

Figure 2 illustrates these three types of claims and their corresponding bounds. The fact that these three types of claims involve different specifications can lead to a paradoxical outcome in claims support. All of these claims are based on statistical testing involving the appropriate null hypothesis, usually conducted at the 95% confidence level (Type I error of 5%).

In this technical report we will consider the problem created by these different specifications and explore the likelihood of a claims conflict.

This technical report appears as:
Ennis, D. M. (2017). Claiming Superiority and Equivalence Simultaneously. IFPress, 20(2) 3-4.

Download this technical report here:
Claiming Superiority and Equivalence Simultaneously

Upcoming Webinar

September 21, 2017

Large TURF Problems: Finding Custom Solutions


Announcing the release of the 2016 Webinar Series Package!

Offered at a discounted rate of 50% off regular price, this package contains recordings of all four webinars offered during the 2016 Quarterly Webinar Series.

Create Your Own Webinar Package


Webinar calendar


Become a Colleague!

Join now to gain access to our technical reports, presentations, and more!

Click here to login or join.

Student Award

Now accepting applications for the
2017 Institute for Perception Student Award

site search