Journal Article: The relative sensitivities of same-different and identification judgment models to perceptual dependence (1993)

Abstract:
Probabilistic models of same-different and identification judgments are compared (within each paradigm) with regard to their sensitivity to perceptual dependence or the degree to which the underlying psychological dimensions are correlated. Three same-different judgment models are compared. One is a step function or decision bound model and the other two are probabilistic variants of a similarity model proposed by Shepard. Three types of identification models are compared: decision bound models, a probabilistic multidimensional scaling model, and probabilistic models based on the Shepard-Luce choice rule. The decision bound models were found to be most sensitive to perceptual dependence, especially when there is considerable distributional overlap. The same-different model based on the city-block metric and an exponential decay similarity function, and the corresponding identification model were found to be particularly insensitive to perceptual dependence. These results suggest that if a Shepard-type similarity function accurately describes behavior, then under typical experimental conditions it should be difficult to see the effects of perceptual dependence. This result provides strong support for a perceptual independence assumption when using these models. These theoretical results may also play an important role in studying different decision rules employed at different stages of identification training.

This article appears as:
Ennis, D.M. and Ashby, F.G. (1993). The relative sensitivities of same-different and identification judgment models to perceptual dependence. Psychometrika, 58(2), 257-279.

Colleagues can request this journal article here:
The relative sensitivities of same-different and identification judgment models to perceptual dependence

Not a Colleague? Click here to join for free!

site search



Upcoming Webinar

March 16, 2017
2PM EDT

Preference without a Significant Sensory Difference? A Solution

__________________

Announcing the release of the 2016 Webinar Series Package!

Offered at a discounted rate of 50% off regular price, this package contains recordings of all four webinars offered during the 2016 Quarterly Webinar Series.

Create Your Own Webinar Package

__________________

Webinar calendar

Membership

Become a Colleague!

Join now to gain access to our technical reports, presentations, and more!

Click here to login or join.

Latest Technical Report

Societies